« A Saturday of Dots | Main | Scenes From My Hometown »
September 11, 2006
The Luxury of Innocence
I've been thinking about this post for a week. Not surprisingly, I don't have anything unique. I don't have any truths about today that the rest of you don't already know.
I was getting ready for class that morning. To defer my big student loans while I was getting my cooking career underwy, I was taking a writing class and two literature classes at a community college. I'd just landed a job with a local foodie rag, which would eventually lead to a gig teaching culinary classes, which led to my catering business. But on that day, I'd yet to write my first article and I had no idea what I was going to do with the culinary education I'd spent the last year and a half gaining. All I knew was I was back where I'd started - English classes.
I was dawdling online instead of getting dressed. Tori Amos' website was previewing a song from her rather unimpressive cover album Strange Little Girls. That day's selection was "Happiness is a Warm Gun". I wasn't impressed. Within a few notes I knew that I preferred the cover that The Breeders. I didn't like how Tori sampled news stories about gun violence into the song. Too heavy-handed. She's dragging this shit out for ten minutes? Please. I don't need to be bashed over the head by how the song ties into modern violence. Duh.
As I listened, I hopped around the web, like I always do, alternating between my email, my web communities, and the news, like I always do. During a brief trip to Yahoo News, I noticed a headline about a plane hitting the World Trade Center. I figured it was a mishap, like one that had happened a few years earlier that barely registered a blip. I surfed away, eventually getting up to brush my teeth and get on with my day.
Between brushing my teeth and getting dressed, I realized I hadn't checked the weather in my morning surfing. Not wanting to get sucked back in, I headed to the TV instead of the computer to check the local news.
I remember the spot where I was standing in the living room. When we rearranged the furniture a few months later, I was secretly thrilled that I'd never be able to stand in that exact spot again.
The first plane had hit. Maybe the second had, too. I don't recall for sure. I don't recall much.
I remember being in the hallway by the bookcase when I heard that the Pentegon had been hit. I was looking for my phone to call my mom. All I remember of that conversation was saying, "This is bad. This is bad," over and over.
I got my head together enough to try to call my teacher, but got her voice mail. At a complete loss of what to do, I left for class.
I live just south of the airport, and my class was just north of the airport. The highway connecting the two runs under the flight path of all the jets coming from the east. I knew that all planes had been ordered down at that point, and I watched their bellies, one by one, as they came over me to land.
I had never in my life been as frightened as I was, watching those planes - so many of them - landing above me. Their silence over the next three days served as a constant reminder that the world had changed, right down to the background white noise of my home several thousand miles away from the attacks.
I walked into class a few minutes late. Everyone was taking a pop quiz.
A fucking quiz?
Don't you people know that our world is ending?
I took a seat by the door because figured I'd need to run out of the room to puke at some point during the class.
Turns out, no one else in the room knew what had happened. That was the last moment in my life in which I'd be in a room of Americans who had been afforded the luxury of innocence.
Despite my news/info junkie tendancies, I couldn't watch any of the news coverage. When I got home from school, I parked the TV on Nickelodeon and proceeded to watch nothing but "Spongebob Squarepants" for the better part of a week. Occasionally I'd flip to MTV or VH1, but they kept playing Jeff Buckley's Hallelujah set to images of NYC so I stopped.
I didn't cry.
I just wanted to sleep. But I have trouble sleeping when I'm stressed, so before bed every night, I downed a handful of Tylenol PM, which kept me hazy during most of my waking hours.
I didn't listen to music. I couldn't risk bringing any emotions to the surface because I knew that when they surfaced, they would drown me.
I cooked. I made every comfort food I could find. Cuban Arroz con Pollo. Southern baked chicken and dressing. Lasagna.
I don't know how many days passed before I cried. It happened while watching an episode of Behind the Music featuring Blind Melon. I never liked them. When Shannon Hoon's widow cried about the daughter he left behind when he died of a heroin overdose, I finally heaved sobs for every child who'd been orphaned that week.
A year later, I spent the day driving around St. Louis with my camera, taking photos. I snapped shots of the American flags everywhere, from the drive-thru window at Burger King to the antenneas of every car on a used car lot. I stood on the patio of a restaurant next to the runway and took photos of planes taking flight. I took beautiful photos of the sun shining through the Gateway Arch. A series of those photos in black and white hang on my dining room wall. They've been there for so long that I don't instantly think of why I took them every time I look at them.
There are two photos I took that day that, if I ever happen to lose my copies of them, I'll still be able to envision them in my mind's eye. I'll never forget them.
This is a gas station B. goes by twice a day, since it's near his train station. Five years ago today, the owner of the station placed the words "Act of war. Nuke now." on the board. A year later, this is what remained.
It's easy to declare war when you're too fucking lazy to maintain your message and someone else is doing your fighting.
This was taken on a bench beneath the Gateway Arch. I have no idea who this woman is. She sat there with her shopping bag clutched in her hands, head bowed, the entire time I was there while her husband and young son played nearby in the grass.
I wanted to sit on the bench next to her and cry. Instead, I kept my distance, only getting as close to her as my zoom lens allowed.
Today, I once again vowed that if the TV was turned on, it would be to kids shows. Clara Jane and I stayed in our jammies. We painted and played with Play-Doh and cookie cutters. We ate chicken noodle soup for lunch. We took a warm bubble bath to clean up all the paint, Play-Doh and chicken soup. We read from her big Curious George book and watched some "Sesame Street".
Elmo's World today was about firefighters.
I folded my arms over the back of the couch, laid my head down, and sobbed.
When I looked up, Clara Jane was watching me, looking concerned. I smiled and told her everything was okay.
It's not.
She asked for her slippers. I went to her room to fetch them, taking advantage of the privacy to release the pressure valve. I gave myself 30 seconds to sob as hard as I could into the back of one of her stuffed Basset hounds before pulling my shit together. I took her on my lap and we sat on the couch, watching Elmo while I put the pink slippers on her feet.
At naptime, she did something she's never done before. She said, "I want to sleep in the big bed" as she ran into my bedroom, the soles of those slippers slapping the new floor.
We crawled into bed, and I figured she was just playing the game she calls "Uppie Uppie" where she gets on our bed, pretends to sleep, and then bounces like a monkey.
Instead, we laid there and I asked, "Do you want to snuggle?"
Clara Jane's not much of a snuggler. She's got far better things to do. I understand this, as I'm not a snuggler either. But today, she looked at me and nodded.
So we snuggled under the down comforter, resting and quiet, save for several outbursts of tickling and giggling. Eventually I moved her to her bed. She needed to sleep and I needed to have some time away from her to get my emotions in order.
Today I've seen several mentions around the web of people saying they don't understand the sadness people are feeling today. 9/11 wasn't the biggest event in history and we need to just get over it.
I can only think that these ideas were presented by people who are young enough that they didn't get to experience the luxury of innocence for as long as I did. Five years is a long time to a 20-year-old. They've spent a quarter of their lives living like this. Maybe it seems more normal to them than it does to me.
I was almost 29 five years ago. I think people in my generation, the ones who experienced the attacks somewhat near the middle of their lives, are going to be the ones who have the hardest time letting this go. Or, rather, we have a unique perspective of having half of our lives "before" and half "after". I don't know if I feel sorry for the younger ones because less of their lives will be spent not entertaining the idea of people flying planes into buildings on purpose, or if I envy them for being able to normalize it and move on.
Now I understand a little more about what Vietnam and Kennedy's assassination meant to my parents' generation. And what Pearl Harbor meant to my grandparents' generation. The events they saw weren't the biggest events in history, that's true. But they were the biggest events in their history, and that matters. A lot.
I can't change that this is the world that my child lives in. I can protect her from it for a little while, but it's there, and she'll know. But I don't want her to know now. I don't want her to feel like she has to comfort me because of what I know and what I saw.
Not yet.
Posted by Robin at September 11, 2006 02:04 PM
Comments
Thank You for that post.
I have been avoiding the news and radio today myself. I was 29 when it happend and I feel those moments and days spent after will be with me always.
Posted by: Tami at September 11, 2006 04:04 PM
Finally... someone who gets it. It's the blog-world lost its mind today with people who don't understand why I still cry as hard as I cried five years ago. For me it's called compassion... as they rang the bells during the Memorial Service today it was like a knife through me, just pure pain, remembering what I watched that day as the towers fell, and feeling a million screams. Compassion. For those died, for those who survive. It's such a simple concept, and yet so many people lack it. I love you, sweets. Kiss that sweet one for me.
Posted by: Zuly at September 11, 2006 05:20 PM
My 7th graders have NEVER had 9/11 explained to them. They barely remember what had happened. I ended up doing all the explaining, and even though it's been 5 years, the thought of "This is too unbelievable to have really happened" kept going through my head.
My husband even remarked "When is 9/11 going to just be a normal day?" when he came home. Pffffttt to him, but I know someday it'll be like Pearl Harbor--something else my kids have never heard of.
Posted by: allison at September 11, 2006 05:26 PM
I couldn't even write about today. I just couldn't. I had nothing that would sum up the ache that I can still feel five years later.
Those photos will haunt me as well.
Posted by: Dixie at September 11, 2006 05:27 PM
beautiful. i feel you, sister! i had to write my piece while bebe napped today. i cried for a good solid two hours. whoever said there is such a thing as closure lied.
Posted by: kara joy at September 11, 2006 09:41 PM
I'm torn. I was at work (the newspaper), and we put out an extra -- half-convinced we'd be redoing it all any minute, as we lived in the capital city where the president's brother was governor. (The biggest news, thankfully, was they sent all the gov't. workers home early and closed the malls.)
But on the one-year anniversary I was in a hospital bed, trying to figure out why in the hell events several states away were sucking up all the TV time, when my daughter was lying dead down the hallway. Why wasn't the headline about our Annie? Why did I have to watch the towers falling again, knowing thousands were killed, when I'd just held Annie as she died the day before? I was actually jeolous of those grieving families -- they'd had years with their loved ones, we had minutes.
This weekend... Sept. 11 is my sister in law's birthday. I had my hide-the-tears-from Livia moment in the laundry room -- but it was for the lost grand birthday celebration we could have had for Annie and Danielle.
You must think I'm horrible. I'm very glad that somebody cares so much about the anniversary; and grateful that your readers include teachers who can get across to the kids who don't remember life before, as well as readers who still care enough to cry.
I just can't get worked up about Sept. 11. But I'm so grateful that you all can. (See? Torn.)
Love and peace to us all.
Posted by: Mary at September 12, 2006 08:48 AM
Great post.
Posted by: barbara at September 12, 2006 08:54 AM
Yours turned out much better than my crappy, ultimately-scrapped attempt did. Thank you.
Posted by: michelle/weaker vessel at September 13, 2006 12:40 AM
I couldn't watch the coverage on Monday, and it's five years later. Just because time goes on, we don't forget the pain and and the anguish we all went thru that day. It's a day that changed our lives forever.
Posted by: Cassie at September 13, 2006 03:06 PM
i know i am a few days late in commenting... but i am just catching up on posts.
i live in New York. i lived here when it happened. in fact, i lived about a mile and a half from ground zero. i heard the first plane hit in my apartment and watched both towers go down from my roof. for weeks afterwards you could see the smoke and for months afterwards you could smell the still burning steel. that day and the days that followed are burned into my memory. seeing the thousands of posters with photos of missing people, the inch thick layer of ash that lay on everything in downtown manhattan, inabiltiy to use your phone to tell people that you were ok (or find out if your friends were ok) is something that is not easily forgotten.
i think it's important to remember what happened. i felt it was important for people to go down to ground zero when they visited me. i wanted people to see how bad it really was and continued to be for almost a year after. but more importantly i wanted to get back to my life, however altered it was going to be.
this year i was on the subway coming into work and the driver announced that at 8:46 there would be a moment of silence then another at 9:08. at 8:46 he stopped the train and no one spoke, moved or sneezed for a full minute (no small feat at rush hour) and that was the first time i cried.
Posted by: libbyfish at September 15, 2006 01:06 PM
Zuly and Libby, on Monday I thought often about how I couldn't even begin to imagine what the day must have felt like for New Yorkers and near-NYers like you. Thank you for giving me a little insight.
Mary, I said it before and I'll say it again: personal tragedy trumps abstract far-away tragedy. You have every right to feel that way. I'd be concerned if you felt otherwise.
Allison, I'm amazed that kids that old don't remember 9/11. But then I thought about it - five years before I was in 7th grade, the hostages were taken in Iran. I remember that, but it didn't mean anything to me. I guess that's the relativity of time.
Posted by: Robin at September 15, 2006 03:07 PM






